Business Case Analysis for Litigation
Business Case Analysis to Strengthen Litigation Strategy
Understanding the business facts underlying a dispute can provide an invaluable guide to legal strategy. A business case analysis for litigation examines the factual basis of a claim within the context of the company, industry, business practices, and circumstances at the time. This analysis helps attorneys evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of a case and support applications for summary judgment. It also guides settlement discussions and informs litigation strategy.
However, analyzing complex business issues requires more than reviewing the allegations and documents. It requires an understanding of how businesses actually operate and how decisions are made. It also involves evaluating reasonable business practices and the alternatives available under the circumstances.
To address these challenges H.S. Grace & Company, Inc. draws on a team of senior executives and professionals with extensive experience in major U.S. and global corporations. We assemble specialized teams with the industry, functional, and executive expertise needed to quickly understand complex business issues and explain their significance to the litigation.
What Does H.S. Grace & Company, Inc. Analyze in a Business Litigation Case?
- Was the conduct consistent with reasonable business practice?
- Was there precedent for the action within the company or industry?
- How did the conduct relate to applicable regulatory or legal requirements?
- How and why were the business decisions made?
- Who participated in or influenced those decisions?
- What financial considerations affected the decisions?
- What information was available to the decision-makers at the time?
- What other options or courses of action were reasonably available?
- How did industry practices and conditions affect the decisions?
- How do these factors relate to the allegations and other facts of the case?
Together, the answers are brought together in a thoughtful analysis that places the facts of the dispute within their real-world business context. By evaluating those facts against reasonable business practices and the circumstances existing at the time, HSG provides attorneys with a stronger factual foundation for developing litigation strategy.
How Does Business Experience Help Evaluate the Facts of a Case?
Complex business litigation often turns on questions that cannot be answered by documents alone. Evaluating whether a business decision was reasonable requires knowledge of how comparable businesses operate and how executives make decisions. It also requires understanding the information available and the practices customary within a particular industry or period.
HSG’s senior business professionals bring this real-world perspective to the analysis. Their experience helps attorneys distinguish significant business facts from peripheral issues, identify questions that warrant further investigation, and evaluate disputed conduct within the context in which the decisions were actually made.
How Can Business Case Analysis Support Attorneys Throughout Litigation?
HSG’s business case analysis can support counsel at multiple stages of a dispute and provide valuable insight throughout the litigation process, from early case assessment and discovery through dispositive motions, settlement, mediation, arbitration, and trial preparation. By examining the business facts and circumstances underlying a dispute, the analysis can help counsel identify key issues, evaluate competing explanations of events, focus discovery, assess the significance of business decisions and practices, and develop a fact-based approach to litigation strategy.
In addition, when a matter requires broader strategic or investigative support, HSG’s Litigation Consulting services can provide additional analysis throughout the dispute. When particular business issues require formal expert opinions for deposition or trial, HSG can also provide experienced professionals through its Expert Witness Testimony services.
Experienced Business Leaders Analyzing Complex Litigation
HSG draws on senior executives and professionals with extensive experience in complex business matters. Their expertise includes corporate governance, finance and accounting, mergers and acquisitions, executive compensation, real estate, regulatory matters, and business conduct and practices. Accordingly, for each engagement, HSG assembles a team whose experience matches the specific issues, industry, and circumstances of the case.
Meet Our Team of Advisors →
Frequently Asked Questions About Business Case Analysis
How does business case analysis differ from traditional legal analysis?
Legal analysis focuses on applicable laws, legal standards, precedents, and the legal merits of claims and defenses. Business case analysis complements this work by examining the commercial realities underlying a dispute, including business practices, management decisions, financial considerations, industry conditions, and operational constraints. H.S. Grace & Company, Inc. brings senior executive and board-level experience to this process, providing attorneys with a practical business perspective that can strengthen their understanding of complex commercial disputes. Learn more about our Litigation Consulting services.
Can business case analysis identify weaknesses in a claim or defense?
Yes. Business case analysis can help identify unsupported assumptions, gaps in evidence, inconsistencies in business explanations, and alternative interpretations of disputed conduct. By examining decisions and actions within their commercial and operational context, experienced business professionals can help attorneys evaluate the factual strengths and weaknesses of claims or defenses. H.S. Grace & Company, Inc. applies practical business experience and objective analysis to clarify significant issues and support the development of informed litigation strategies.
How does business case analysis help attorneys focus discovery?
Business case analysis can help attorneys identify the business decisions, transactions, documents, and individuals most relevant to a commercial dispute. By understanding how an organization operates and how significant decisions were made, experienced business professionals can help counsel recognize critical information, evaluate competing explanations, and prioritize areas requiring further investigation. H.S. Grace & Company, Inc. provides business expertise that supports more focused discovery and a clearer understanding of the underlying facts. Explore our Expert Witness Testimony services to learn how specialized business analysis can also support expert opinions and testimony.
Let’s Work Together
H.S. Grace brings senior-level business experience to the analysis of complex disputes. Contact us to discuss how a business case analysis can help clarify the issues and support your litigation strategy.